“There’s something off about it,” Cortes reportedly said. “I’ve played with Judge. I know how good he is, but that kind of power? It just raises questions. MLB needs to do the right thing and test him immediately.”

The remarks have ignited a firestorm of debate across the league. Some view Cortes’ comments as a bitter accusation from a former teammate who may harbor resentment after leaving the Yankees. Others argue that his concerns highlight a broader issue in baseball, where suspicion often follows any superhuman performance.

MLB has not yet responded to Cortes’ demand, and the Yankees organization has refrained from making any official statements regarding the controversy. However, Judge’s teammates have quickly come to his defense, dismissing Cortes’ claims as baseless and insisting that Judge’s success stems from hard work and dedication.

Yankees manager Aaron Boone addressed the situation, saying, “Aaron Judge is one of the hardest-working players in this league. He’s been tested countless times throughout his career. This is just noise.”

Meanwhile, fans remain divided. While many continue to celebrate Judge’s achievement, others wonder whether Cortes’ comments will prompt MLB to take action. If the league decides to test Judge, it could set a precedent for how similar accusations are handled in the future.

For now, Aaron Judge remains the talk of baseball, not just for his record-breaking home run but also for the controversy surrounding it. Whether MLB will respond to Nestor Cortes’ ultimatum remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: this drama is far from over.