The Yankees’ Stanton injury update fails to convince the concerned fanbase and has created more confusion than clarity.

Fifteen games into the 2025 season, the New York Yankees find themselves treading water with an 8-7 record in the competitive American League East. Yet beneath the surface of their early-season performance lurks an increasingly contentious storyline: the continued absence of Giancarlo Stanton and the puzzling updates surrounding his recovery.

The power-hitting designated hitter, who boasts 429 career home runs and carries a $325 million contract running through 2028, has yet to make his season debut due to elbow discomfort that first appeared during spring training. Rather than providing clarity, manager Aaron Boone’s latest update has only deepened fan frustration and sparked more questions than answers.

Boone masters art of confusion: ‘Moving around more outside’

Prior to Sunday’s matchup with the San Francisco Giants, Boone attempted to deliver positive news regarding Stanton’s progress, noting that the veteran is “taking swings in the cage” and “starting to move around more outside.”

Giancarlo Stanton is with the team in New York and continues to hit off the high-velocity Trajekt machine. Stanton is also "starting to move around more outside," Aaron Boone said.

— Bryan Hoch ⚾️ (@BryanHoch) April 13, 2025

Though seemingly innocuous on the surface, this peculiar phrasing—reported by MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch—immediately triggered reactions across social media. On X (formerly Twitter), bewildered fans didn’t hold back their confusion and sarcasm.

“Did this guy get into a car accident?! Why are they talking like that?” wrote one perplexed fan. Another compared the update to “a bear slowly waking from its winter slumber,” while a third simply commented: “Dying laughing at that last part.”

Boone offered no explanation of what “moving around outside” actually entails in relation to Stanton’s elbow recovery. He also made no mention of the calf soreness that had previously limited Stanton’s activity during spring training—an omission that only added to the confusion.

A pattern of ambiguity in Stanton injury update

Charles Wenzelberg

For Yankees fans, this communication style feels all too familiar. Since his arrival via trade from Miami following the 2017 campaign, the now 35-year-old Stanton has battled numerous injuries—hamstring strains, quad issues, and knee inflammation among them—with each setback accompanied by similarly vague updates.

The 2025 season is proving no different, with the organization’s nebulous messaging leading many to speculate whether the full extent of Stanton’s condition is being withheld or if the team itself lacks a definitive diagnosis.

While Boone may have intended to convey that Stanton is progressing toward baseball activities such as base running or fielding drills, his choice of words has instead fueled suspicion that there might be more significant concerns behind closed doors.

Return timeline remains elusive

Conspicuously absent from Boone’s update was any hint of a timeline for Stanton’s potential return. The manager provided no details on whether the slugger has resumed full-intensity running or throwing programs. The only concrete information shared was that Stanton continues taking swings with a high-velocity Trajekt pitching machine, which simulates actual major league pitching.

Beyond this solitary detail, Yankees fans remain in an information vacuum—parsing cryptic statements for clues while bracing for what many have come to view as an inevitable extended absence.

The silver lining in Stanton’s absence has been the emergence of Ben Rice, a 2021 12th-round selection from Dartmouth who has seized his unexpected opportunity. The 25-year-old has appeared in 14 of New York’s first 16 contests, posting an impressive .250/.320/.518 slash line with four home runs, two doubles, a triple, and 11 RBIs across 56 plate appearances.

Growing scrutiny on Boone’s communications

As injured players continue to accumulate, Boone’s approach to injury reporting faces increasing scrutiny. With Gerrit Cole, Marcus Stroman, and Luis Gil also sidelined, fans and media alike are demanding greater transparency regarding player health and recovery timelines.

The passionate Yankees fan base, accustomed to championship expectations and organizational accountability, has grown increasingly frustrated with the lack of substantive updates—particularly regarding a player who commands such a significant portion of the team’s payroll.

The core of fan discontent isn’t necessarily tied to Stanton’s recovery pace but rather to the organization’s refusal to provide a framework for understanding his progress.

Communication conundrum continues

Despite their injury challenges, the Yankees remain in second place in the AL East, trailing only the Toronto Blue Jays. However, maintaining this position in baseball’s most competitive division will depend largely on how quickly they can reintegrate key contributors.

Stanton, who connected for 24 home runs in 108 games during the 2024 campaign, retains the ability to transform an inning with a single swing. Yet as mid-April passes, neither Boone, the medical staff, nor Stanton himself has offered concrete insights into when fans might witness that impact again.

However, the delicate balance between optimistic messaging and realistic expectations proves particularly challenging with injury updates. In Stanton’s case, the Yankees continue to navigate this territory unsuccessfully, creating more confusion than clarity.

Until more definitive information emerges or Stanton returns to visible on-field activities, fans will remain dependent on deciphering ambiguous phrases like “moving around outside”—a frustratingly familiar position for followers of a team that should know better than most that in New York, communication matters almost as much as performance.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.